Okay, so @Cheschire Cat; and I have two characters and I came up with three different plots. We can’t decide on one. We have agreed to put up a discussion thing so you guys can decide.
Idea 1 Votes-2
Okay! So Moonclaw is going to start out just like any other shecat. Then, I’ll put up a finder for a loner to attack her while she is hunting. She gets injured and Brindlestep cares for her. She realizes Brindles true personality and truly loves him.

Idea 2 Votes-3
Moonclaw is just like any other shecat. Flirty, all about the looks. Then said loner catnaps her and returns her to the clan, expecting the loners kits. She is ashamed and tells Brindlestep and he agrees to say they are his. (Bluefur and...darn I forget the other cats name, Thorn something I think, basis) She realizes that Brindle actually does care and she returns the Affection.

Idea 3 Votes- 1
Same beginning. Then I’ll put up a finder for a loner (I kinda want this loner thing in there!) who she secretly meets with while being together with Brindle. Soon she is expecting loners kits and loner convinces her to leave the Clan with him. She sneaks out during the night and stays with loner for a few days. Then loner starts abusing her. She escapes during the night, tired of the physical abuse, and returns to ShadowClan and back to Brindlestep. Wounded and tired, she gushed out all her feelings before passing out. Unfortunately, the kits do not make it and Moonclaw is devastated. Brindle finds his way back to her and Moony and him become inseparable. Then they have kits of their own.



We can’t decide!

Originally Posted by FadingEchoes (Post 434251) I like idea 2 or 3! Can I make the loner? :D @ScarredSecrets

Originally Posted by ScarredSecrets (Post 434287) I’ll wait till I get a majority vote XD