Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

Who do you think is better? Personally I love tawnypelt although she has little to no screen time in arc 1 and arc 2 . She had so much potential as tigerstars daughter and her and her brother make an amazing pair . The most intresting thing that happen in arc 2 book 1 [For tawnypelt] was her rat bite cri

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

I like Brambleclaw ngl Tawnypelt is... to stubborn for me :P @honeyfern0

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

BRAMBLECLAW!!! I love him for the fact he is almost exactly like his father except the murderous part.

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

I CHANGE MY ANSWER TO TAWNY LIKE GOD BRAMBLE

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

Bramble star is garbage. Tawnypelt supremacy

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

I believe in Tawnypelt Supremacy as well

1. Tawnypelt is much better, she might have left but thats because she's just so shy. The third and fourth series made Brambleclaw/star a giant flop. Second series bramble was much better and dont even get me started on Broken Code bramble smh.

2. Bramble x squirrel is toxic. Bramble pays no attention to Squirrel whatsoever and evens cuts her out of his life completely without hesitation when she lied about Jay/Lion/Holly. I feel like the erins just made him pick squirrel deputy to end this but NO It doesnt stop does it?

3. Squirrel is so loyal to bramble even after all he did to her and I think thats uhhh unfair

4. When Rowanstar was left by his clan for Darktail, Tawnypelt stayed by his side (YOU WILL NOT TELL ME JUST BC THEY WERE MATES) and Tigerheart who also stays, later goes missing to ship with Dove which is not cool

Those are all my reasons BAHAHHAH I LUV TAWNY OVER BRAMBLE

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

Why is the thread symbol RiverClan/ThunderClan, not ShadowClan/ThunderClan?

Re: Brambleclaw vs Tawnypelt?! Whos best and why?
 

Definitely Tawnypelt. Her chatacter was always so interesting to me, wheras Bramble wasn't very well-rounded imo

When Bramble made his first appearance, i was sorta indifferent to him, but he just got progressively worse and worse throughout his life, especially in regards to Squirrelflight. Tawnypelt was always my favorite