[aleka!]

Okay. But imagine what Thistleclaw was feeling. His mate was killed. And there's also the apparent thing that he did go to StarClan when he died, but was chased out by Bluestar. He actually did never break the code, and he also didn't try to kill Bluestar, or try to harm his clammates *cough cough Ashfur* and yes, there is the fact that he helped "create" not one, but two of the most evil cats ever in the forests. Yes, he was a bit over-serious with partrolling, but so was Mudclaw, and yet he's in Statclan (unless I read something wrong XD)