[BEAR.]

Originally Posted by Celestial

This really isn’t an evil, horrible, dictator, gory, stupid leader
But I still think pinestar
He was good for most of his life but a bad choice I believe he made was when he left for twoleg’s, I would’ve respected resigning or even turning to become a rouge but it kind of makes me sad that he made that choice in the end game.

he did what he thought would make him happy, and you can't really fault him for that after he spent the majority of his life trying to do the best for his Clan.

the only real issue i have with him leaving is he screwed over sunstar by not giving up his last leader life.

IMHO the worst leader in the series is brokenstar because nothing he did benefitted his Clan in any regard. he just brought chaos and destruction.