[Mango]

Originally Posted by Spoopy Potato

"StarClan gives us vague prophecies and omens because they don't know the outcome for sure. They help us in the long run when some cat that's smarter than some members of StarClan figures it out. I'm not saying StarClan is unintelligent; they're wise is all I can say. But they don't solve our problems."
"What true four Clans? There are 5, if you don't count StarClan. RiverClan has been here as long as any of the Clans, and longer than SkyClan. How would RiverClan be considered as a 'fake' Clan?" Justicepaw saw where this was going. They were going to bicker over RiverClan. She felt like she was betraying her Clan by defending an opposing Clan, but she wasn't actually helping them in any way, shape, or form. She was just verbally fighting someone in their defense. She didn't think that counted as being a traitor. Did it? She wasn't going to think about that right now... Justicepaw snapped back to attention once Pikerunner started talking again. Oh, is that how it is? she thought, listening to the headstrong warrior go on and on about his opinion. "Mhm," she replied, looking as uninterested as if she was about to go do the most boring errand in the world. "I see. So basically, what you're saying is that we should not give a care about RiverClan's needs? Interesting. I thought WindClan warriors were smarter than that."
The apprentice glared at Pikerunner, her eyes glinting with a slight bit of annoyance. She wasn't feeling like her happy old self right now, and she could give a round of applause, perhaps a standing ovation, to Pikerunner; the one who'd ruined her smiley attitude.
Her eyes widened. "Okay, there's an endless list of flaws in that plan. First, you'd be separating mentors, apprentices, friends, warriors, family, queens, mates, and more. Second, don't you think RiverClan would rebel? Third, RiverClan would definitely not agree to that. All the apprentices would need new mentors and the mentors would need whole new apprentices. The apprentices and mentors probably wouldn't trust or treat each other fairly, considering they're from different Clans. Fourth, the queens and mates wouldn't be able to raise their kit(s) together. And that's only if you place the kits in the same Clan as one of their parents. Fifth, the friends might be depressed at losing most of their friends. Most cats, maybe even warriors, would have to learn all over again how to hunt in that Clan's territory. Also, why wouldn't you put them in ThunderClan? ThunderClan's defending them, so they probably care more about the RiverClan cats; therefore, they'd treat them better than all the other Clans who are practically begging for their downfall and extinction." She was only just beginning to list the flaws in that plan. However, she glanced at Pikerunner, hoping he'd gotten the idea.

Pikerunner shrugged,” Listen Justicepaw, we’re just obeying the orders of Starclan, it’s not our job to question them, we should just do what they, want, we’d tell them to join one of the four clans. Excluding Starclan. The queens could chose to take her kits with her and mate. The apprentices could chose to go with there mentor, everyone would be allowed to chose, and the four clans...excluding Starclan, would treat them as any other warrior. They’d adapt. Besides Riverclan is evil.” He added annoyed at how upity the apprentice was being.