Ivypool or Dovewing

[Cove]

I personally prefer Ivypool for many reasons:

• She risks her life to spy for her clan
• She just naturally awesome
• She doesn’t complain and isn’t needy

[Wingnettle]

I really liked Ivypool's character. She changed a lot and matured in a hard situation, and stayed loyal to her clan in the end. However I identified myself more with Dovewing because of her character and her difficulties in handling her powers.

[Rxcket_p]

Ivypool is one of my major favorites (That is very high standards, considering I hate thunderclan in the books. I love Ivypool for all the same reasons as the lovely @Cove

And I also hate Dovewing's guts so uh-

[Thornwolf]

Both are technically equal...

[Weekend-Wondering]

Ivypool. I like Ivypool better. Though Dovewing is awesome too, Ivypool just-
WOW

[Thornwolf]

I think that video of someone explaining why ivy and Dove's rivalry sucked made me question things

[Overlyobsessedfan1]

Ivypool!

[Raven~]

Ivypool is much more developed in my opinion, would do anything for her Clan, and isn’t a spoiled brat like three-quarters of ThunderClan seriously what is wrong with ThunderClan these days?
She was a major character in Omen of the Stars, yet didn’t have a superpower which made her a prime example of work hard get rewarded and that sort of thing. Also she didn’t leave ThunderClan like Dovewing, so there’s another thing. Also I just love Ivypool in general

[Pine'Paw]

Ivypool! She just feels more mature and loyal. I mean, Ivypool did stay in her clan. She was brave and even though she did train with the dark forest, she did see right from wrong and stayed loyal to her clan. She was a brave warrior and fought for ThunderClan with pure loyalty.

She also, like Raven has mentioned, isn't a spoiled brat, like most ThunderClan. I hold her character as somebody that deserves all the respect she's given. She was a major character in Omen Of The Stars without powers, but still stood strong like any powered or non-powered cat.

She's also just generally my second favorite character and I adore her! I never really liked Dovewing, Ivypool just seemed better to me.

Edit:This is why I have a plush of her

[Hailbelly]

Team Dovewing!
She was deffo wayyyyy less self-centered than Ivypool and ik this is controversial but I love love love Dove x Tiger it can be viewed as sort of escapism, this point made by Bright Guardian Akira that are exactly how I feel Dove x Tiger is (in my own words since I have a memory as bad as the authors memory of minor characters) It serves as escapism with Tigerheart's dark forest training being at night if he doesn't sleep he doesn't have to do it and with Dovewing's extended senses making her more sensitive to sounds and other things and at night cats are asleep so she gets to escape her constant stress to sort of escape it with Tigerheart. Like how sweet is that?