worst leader?

[Fireflower]

who do you think is/has been the worst leader ever in the books?this can mean dumbest,craziest,and just plain most evil leader.

for me i say

 

rowanstar and onestar,cause i cant pick one

[Mango]

What about Brokenstar Tigerstar the first?

[pomegranate]

 

I feel like he was very contradictory, splitting apart the clans and then trying to make ammends by fighting and acting like a jerk. Apparently, he did try to be a better father later on, but that still doesn’t change the fact that he was ignorant and horrible.
Not sure if many agree with me? I think Thunderstar does.

[wren]

This really isn’t an evil, horrible, dictator, gory, stupid leader
But I still think pinestar
He was good for most of his life but a bad choice I believe he made was when he left for twoleg’s, I would’ve respected resigning or even turning to become a rouge but it kind of makes me sad that he made that choice in the end game.

[BEAR.]

Originally Posted by Celestial

This really isn’t an evil, horrible, dictator, gory, stupid leader
But I still think pinestar
He was good for most of his life but a bad choice I believe he made was when he left for twoleg’s, I would’ve respected resigning or even turning to become a rouge but it kind of makes me sad that he made that choice in the end game.

he did what he thought would make him happy, and you can't really fault him for that after he spent the majority of his life trying to do the best for his Clan.

the only real issue i have with him leaving is he screwed over sunstar by not giving up his last leader life.

IMHO the worst leader in the series is brokenstar because nothing he did benefitted his Clan in any regard. he just brought chaos and destruction.

[Branch of Life]

Yo I think it’s Firestar XD I don’t know he kind of seemed like a mary sue to me. Not that he did anything wrong 2nd SKYSTAR I won’t give my reasoning...

[Fireflower]

Originally Posted by Silver Fishie

 

I feel like he was very contradictory, splitting apart the clans and then trying to make ammends by fighting and acting like a jerk. Apparently, he did try to be a better father later on, but that still doesn’t change the fact that he was ignorant and horrible.
Not sure if many agree with me? I think Thunderstar does.

Originally Posted by ~Warriorsfan101~

Yo I think it’s Firestar XD I don’t know he kind of seemed like a mary sue to me. Not that he did anything wrong 2nd SKYSTAR I won’t give my reasoning...

i agree with skystar,but what i liked about dawn of the clans is that it showed his view,it shows that no one is just evil.we all have reasons.
but i still hate that idiot.

[SuspiciousMindz]

Originally Posted by Silver Fishie

 

I feel like he was very contradictory, splitting apart the clans and then trying to make ammends by fighting and acting like a jerk. Apparently, he did try to be a better father later on, but that still doesn’t change the fact that he was ignorant and horrible.
Not sure if many agree with me? I think Thunderstar does.

Not sure how far you got, but I hated him.
Especially hated the Star Flower X Clear Sky ship e.e

I almost gave up cause of it

[pomegranate]

Originally Posted by Suspiciousmindz

Not sure how far you got, but I hated him.
Especially hated the Star Flower X Clear Sky ship e.e

I almost gave up cause of it

I finished the Dawn ark, but overall whatever ‘nice’ things he did were overruled by all of the horrible choices he made. Even at the end he still made everything worse by being there, in my opinion. Erins could have made his character a bit better.
I hated all of the ships. Just thought that they were pointless and only made me hate him more.

I’ve only ever thought of giving up in Omen. I felt like most of the characters were just background noise.

[Leucos]

Tigerstar I ( no questions asked ) and now that I think about it firestar is kind a gary stue 'perfect' in everyway it seems I can't believe I used to like him >-< . TigerstarII I honestly think they should have stuck with bumblestripe now that I watched simmys video on it and if you saw my rant thread xD. Blackstar.... He just didn't seem to have enough .. Aw to his personality to me and he didn't even take firestars help the first time in the new prophecy ! -_- . Or maybe he did?can't remember . Aand brokenstar.