Some Random What Ifs

**Dark Flame** · #1 April 14th, 2020, 12:54 PM

So... guys... what do you think would have happened if something happened/didn’t happen? Here are some of my ideas!

If Scourge won the battle with ThunderClan

A lot of people will have different responses. We know that Scourge literally destroyed Tigerstar’s lives in just a little fight, so I reckon the same for Firestar. A moment of silence, please. Thank you. And Scourge and BloodClan would take over the forest. It is very likely that the Clans would be reduced to the camps seen in DotC. But, unlike DotC, the Clans would most likely ally.

If Cinderpelt continued on as a Warrior

FIRST! Warrior name!

I personally have Cinderspirit, Cinderwing or Cinderheart (Reincarnation name).

I also believe the Cinder x Fire ship would happen and they would have their versions of Squirrelflight and Leafpool. Also I think Spottedleaf or Yellowfang would reincarnate instead; Yellowfang due to her ‘curse’ or Spottedleaf because... she’s an one-off. The Squirrel and Bramble prophecy could be replaced as well with _____ and Bramble. The Ashfur drama... I only think that would happen if something like the power of three. Finally, Sand x Dust happens.

So... what about you guys?

**MEAT ANGELS** · #2 April 14th, 2020, 01:10 PM

What if Darktail survived?

>:3 I have a feeling he was planning on Violetshine becoming his mate before she betrayed him.

@Bravekit

**Dark Flame** · #3 April 14th, 2020, 01:17 PM

That makes a lot of sense.
@TeamRiverRipple

**MEAT ANGELS** · #4 April 14th, 2020, 01:20 PM

He was actually pretty possesive over her, and praised her relentlessly. So, mmm, yea.

@Bravekit

**Willowfern** · #5 April 14th, 2020, 01:37 PM

What if Silverstream survived?
Okay, This is a small one, but what if she did survive? Would she go to Thunderclan or would Greystripe still go to Riverclan? Also, What about Millie? Would Greystripe just be friends with her?

**Cloudsky** · #6 April 14th, 2020, 01:39 PM

What if Snowkit lived? Would he have become a warrior, or a Med. cat like the rest?

**Dark Flame** · #7 April 14th, 2020, 02:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Willowfern

What if Silverstream survived?
Okay, This is a small one, but what if she did survive? Would she go to Thunderclan or would Greystripe still go to Riverclan? Also, What about Millie? Would Greystripe just be friends with her?

Hm... I think I should get a little story with this.

Since Silverstream gave birth on ThunderClan territory, I think a patrol might find them after the kits’ births. Obviously, the bury the kits alive drama wouldn’t have happened (that’s Graystripe for you). They would have stayed in TC, and I think Bluestar would understand Graystripe’s emotions (CUE BLUE X OAK!). Graystripe still would have met Millie, but would just be friends. I’m not sure whether she would join TC or stay as a kittypet, or travelling as a rogue. But the clear thing is that Blossomfall, Briarlight and Bumblestripe wouldn’t exist. This also means Blossomfall’s kits wouldn’t exist.

- - -

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloudsky

What if Snowkit lived? Would he have become a warrior, or a Med. cat like the rest?

Hm... I think Snowkit would become a medicine cat. The cats would have to develop sign language though. Other than that, Snowkit would have to go to the elder’s den early. I think his name would be Snowspirit, Snowhawk or Snowheart.

**The Shadow Flower** · #8 April 14th, 2020, 02:02 PM

Why do people ship cinderfire? She’s WAY younger than him!

**MEAT ANGELS** · #9 April 14th, 2020, 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bravekit

Hm... I think I should get a little story with this.

Since Silverstream gave birth on ThunderClan territory, I think a patrol might find them after the kits’ births. Obviously, the bury the kits alive drama wouldn’t have happened (that’s Graystripe for you). They would have stayed in TC, and I think Bluestar would understand Graystripe’s emotions (CUE BLUE X OAK!). Graystripe still would have met Millie, but would just be friends. I’m not sure whether she would join TC or stay as a kittypet, or travelling as a rogue. But the clear thing is that Blossomfall, Briarlight and Bumblestripe wouldn’t exist. This also means Blossomfall’s kits wouldn’t exist.

- - -

Hm... I think Snowkit would become a medicine cat. The cats would have to develop sign language though. Other than that, Snowkit would have to go to the elder’s den early. I think his name would be Snowspirit, Snowhawk or Snowheart.

SNOWHAWK? THE IRONY!! THE PAAAAAAIN!

**Dark Flame** · #10 April 14th, 2020, 02:10 PM

That’s why I said it. THE IRONY!
@TeamRiverRipple